Midwest Petroleum Executive and Leadership Team

May, 2026

Leadership Overview

Midwest Petroleum has 4 executives leading key functions including operations, finance, and strategy.

Driven by a legacy of service, Midwest Petroleum operates corporate-run gasoline and convenience food stores, alongside servicing multiple dealer locations, impacting regional commerce through its extensive retail network.

Leadership Roles at Midwest Petroleum

  • Chief Financial Officer & Vice President, Finance - James Doherty
  • Chief Operating Officer - Walter Vance
  • President - James McNutt
  • Chief Operations Officer - Don Bartoni
  • James Doherty - Chief Financial Officer & Vice President, Finance

    James Doherty, the Chief Financial Officer & Vice President, Finance at Midwest Petroleum, architects the company's financial strategy and oversees all fiscal operations. Doherty manages financial planning, budgeting, and reporting, ensuring robust financial health for the organization's retail and wholesale segments. This executive directs capital allocation, investment strategies, and risk management to support Midwest Petroleum's growth objectives and operational stability. James Doherty's responsibilities extend to managing banking relationships and ensuring compliance with all financial regulations pertinent to the convenience store and fuel retail sectors. The Chief Financial Officer & Vice President, Finance plays a pivotal part in evaluating new business opportunities and optimizing the financial performance of both corporate-run stores and dealer partnerships, thereby securing the company's long-term economic viability.

    Walter Vance - Chief Operating Officer

    Walter Vance, the Chief Operating Officer at Midwest Petroleum, directs the operational framework for the company's extensive network of corporate-run gasoline and convenience food stores. Vance oversees the daily functions critical to maintaining high standards across all retail locations, ensuring seamless integration between fuel services and convenience offerings. This leadership role involves optimizing supply chain logistics and inventory management to support both company-owned outlets and the multiple dealer locations serviced by Midwest Petroleum. Walter Vance drives efficiency improvements and operational excellence, directly impacting customer satisfaction and the company's market presence in Missouri and surrounding regions. The Chief Operating Officer's focus remains on scaling operations effectively while upholding the company's commitment to quality and service delivery across its diverse portfolio.

    James McNutt - President

    James McNutt, the President at Midwest Petroleum, provides overarching strategic direction and executive leadership for the entire organization. McNutt guides the company's vision, ensuring alignment across all departments to achieve its mission of operating successful gasoline and convenience food stores and supporting dealer partners. This role involves fostering a culture of excellence, driving business development, and making critical decisions that shape Midwest Petroleum's market position and future trajectory. James McNutt oversees the integration of corporate strategy with day-to-day operations, ensuring that the company's legacy, established in 1946, continues to inform its modern business practices. The President's leadership is fundamental to maintaining Midwest Petroleum's reputation for quality service and operational integrity within the competitive retail fuel and convenience sector.

    Don Bartoni - Chief Operations Officer

    Don Bartoni, the Chief Operations Officer at Midwest Petroleum, spearheads the strategic execution of operational initiatives across the company's diverse business units. Bartoni focuses on enhancing the efficiency and profitability of Midwest Petroleum's corporate-run gasoline stations and convenience food stores, while also managing the support structures for its dealer network. This leadership position involves driving operational improvements, implementing best practices in retail management, and ensuring consistent service delivery. Don Bartoni collaborates with finance and strategy teams to align operational capabilities with overarching business goals, contributing to market expansion and customer retention. The Chief Operations Officer's oversight ensures that all operational facets, from site management to supply chain coordination, contribute to Midwest Petroleum's sustained success and competitive edge in the regional market.

    Explore Leadership Teams in Convenience Stores, Gas Stations & Liquor Stores

    Frequently Asked Questions Regarding Midwest Petroleum Top Executives and Leadership Team

    Who leads Midwest Petroleum?
    Midwest Petroleum is led by James Doherty (Chief Financial Officer & Vice President, Finance), along with executives such as Walter Vance (Chief Operating Officer) and James McNutt (President).
    Who is part of Midwest Petroleum’s executive team?
    The executive team of Midwest Petroleum includes leaders such as James Doherty (Chief Financial Officer & Vice President, Finance), Walter Vance (Chief Operating Officer), James McNutt (President) and other senior executives.
    How many executives does Midwest Petroleum have?
    Midwest Petroleum has 4 executives leading key business areas.
    What roles are included in Midwest Petroleum’s leadership team?
    The leadership team of Midwest Petroleum includes roles such as Chief Financial Officer & Vice President, Finance, Chief Operating Officer, President, Chief Operations Officer.