First Financial Bank Executive and Leadership Team

October, 2026

Leadership Overview

First Financial Bank has 10 executives leading key functions including corporate strategy, financial oversight, information technology, and regional market management.

Committed to regional economic growth, First Financial Bank delivers comprehensive commercial lending, wealth management, and digital banking solutions to individuals and businesses across the Midwest.

Leadership Roles at First Financial Bank

  • Chief Executive Officer & President - Kyle Goodwin
  • Chief Financial Officer - Jamie Anderson
  • Senior Vice President - Finance and Chief Financial Officer - Paul Cloutier
  • Market President - Joseph McNeill
  • Wealth Regional Market President - Matthew Malafa
  • President, Retail Market Harrisburg - Zac Price
  • President, Market (Butler & Warren) - Jeff Judd
  • Regional President - David Dannemiller
  • Regional President - David Cardell
  • Executive Vice President & Chief Information Officer - Niki Pilotte
  • Kyle Goodwin - Chief Executive Officer & President

    Kyle Goodwin, the Chief Executive Officer & President at First Financial Bank, directs the overarching strategic vision and operational execution for the entire organization. Goodwin architects long-term growth initiatives while overseeing the integration of personal banking, commercial lending, and wealth management services across Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, and Illinois. By aligning the executive leadership team with the core mission of providing accessible financial solutions, the Chief Executive Officer & President ensures consistent performance across all digital and branch channels. This leadership role involves constant engagement with the Board to refine market positioning and enhance shareholder value. Through rigorous oversight of corporate governance and risk management frameworks, Kyle Goodwin maintains the stability of the institution. Ultimately, the Chief Executive Officer & President drives the expansion of the bank's footprint, ensuring that the organization remains a primary financial partner for individuals, businesses, and public-sector customers throughout the regional market.

    Jamie Anderson - Chief Financial Officer

    Jamie Anderson, the Chief Financial Officer at First Financial Bank, manages the fiscal health and capital allocation strategies of the institution. Anderson oversees financial reporting, treasury management, and regulatory compliance to ensure the bank maintains a robust balance sheet. By analyzing market trends across the Midwest, the Chief Financial Officer optimizes investment services and commercial lending profitability. This role requires close collaboration with the executive team to forecast revenue growth and manage operational expenses effectively. Jamie Anderson directs the development of financial models that support the bank's digital transformation and branch expansion efforts. Through precise management of liquidity and capital ratios, the Chief Financial Officer safeguards the organization against economic volatility. Ultimately, Anderson provides the financial intelligence necessary to support the bank's commitment to serving diverse customer segments, ensuring that fiscal discipline remains at the center of all strategic business decisions.
    Jamie Anderson

    Paul Cloutier - Senior Vice President - Finance and Chief Financial Officer

    Paul Cloutier, the Senior Vice President - Finance and Chief Financial Officer at First Financial Bank, executes complex financial planning and analysis to drive organizational efficiency. Cloutier manages the internal audit processes and tax strategies that underpin the bank's commercial lending and wealth management operations. By monitoring regional economic indicators in Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, and Illinois, the Senior Vice President - Finance and Chief Financial Officer identifies opportunities for cost optimization and revenue enhancement. This leadership position involves coordinating with department heads to align departmental budgets with the broader corporate strategy. Paul Cloutier ensures that all financial disclosures meet rigorous regulatory standards while providing actionable insights to the Board. Through the implementation of advanced financial software and reporting tools, the Senior Vice President - Finance and Chief Financial Officer improves the accuracy of performance metrics. Ultimately, Cloutier strengthens the bank's financial foundation, enabling sustained growth across all personal and business banking sectors.

    Joseph McNeill - Market President

    Joseph McNeill, the Market President at First Financial Bank, directs regional business development and client relationship management strategies. McNeill oversees the delivery of commercial lending and treasury management services to local businesses and public-sector entities. By fostering deep connections within the community, the Market President ensures that the bank's personal banking and investment services meet the specific needs of the regional customer base. This leadership role involves managing branch performance and driving loan portfolio growth through targeted outreach and relationship-based sales. Joseph McNeill collaborates with regional teams to implement corporate initiatives while maintaining a focus on local market dynamics. Through the active promotion of the bank's wealth management offerings, the Market President expands the institution's influence in the area. Ultimately, McNeill secures the bank's reputation as a trusted financial partner, driving consistent revenue growth and customer loyalty through dedicated service and strategic market engagement.

    Matthew Malafa - Wealth Regional Market President

    Matthew Malafa, the Wealth Regional Market President at First Financial Bank, leads the strategic expansion of investment services and wealth management solutions. Malafa oversees a team of financial advisors dedicated to providing personalized financial planning and asset management for high-net-worth individuals and businesses. By analyzing market volatility and economic shifts, the Wealth Regional Market President develops tailored investment strategies that align with the bank's broader financial goals. This role involves coordinating with commercial lending teams to provide holistic financial solutions for complex client needs. Matthew Malafa drives the growth of the wealth management division by identifying new market opportunities and enhancing client retention through superior service. Through the implementation of sophisticated portfolio management techniques, the Wealth Regional Market President ensures that clients receive optimal financial guidance. Ultimately, Malafa strengthens the bank's position as a premier wealth management provider, contributing significantly to the institution's overall fee-based revenue and long-term client relationships.

    Zac Price - President, Retail Market Harrisburg

    Zac Price, the President, Retail Market Harrisburg at First Financial Bank, manages the retail banking operations and customer service standards within the designated market. Price oversees branch performance, staff development, and the execution of retail banking strategies to ensure high levels of customer satisfaction. By focusing on the delivery of personal banking and mortgage lending services, the President, Retail Market Harrisburg drives local market share growth. This role involves implementing corporate policies at the branch level while adapting to the unique financial needs of the local community. Zac Price collaborates with regional leadership to optimize branch efficiency and promote digital banking adoption among retail customers. Through the effective management of daily operations and sales targets, the President, Retail Market Harrisburg supports the bank's broader mission of providing accessible financial solutions. Ultimately, Price enhances the bank's local presence, ensuring that retail operations contribute effectively to the institution's overall regional success.
    Zac Price

    Jeff Judd - President, Market (Butler & Warren)

    Jeff Judd, the President, Market (Butler & Warren) at First Financial Bank, directs the strategic growth and operational oversight of banking services within the Butler and Warren regions. Judd manages the integration of commercial lending, treasury management, and personal banking services to serve the diverse needs of the local business and individual customer base. By building strong relationships with community leaders and business owners, the President, Market (Butler & Warren) identifies key opportunities for loan portfolio expansion and deposit growth. This role involves leading branch teams to achieve performance targets while maintaining the bank's commitment to high-quality service. Jeff Judd coordinates with regional executives to align local market activities with the bank's overarching corporate strategy. Through the proactive management of market-specific risks and opportunities, the President, Market (Butler & Warren) ensures the bank remains a dominant financial force in the area. Ultimately, Judd drives regional profitability and strengthens the bank's brand presence.

    David Dannemiller - Regional President

    David Dannemiller, the Regional President at First Financial Bank, oversees the comprehensive banking operations and strategic initiatives across a designated geographic territory. Dannemiller directs the alignment of commercial lending, wealth management, and retail banking services to meet the specific economic demands of the region. By fostering collaboration between branch managers and specialized lending teams, the Regional President ensures the delivery of integrated financial solutions to a broad customer base. This role involves monitoring regional performance metrics and implementing adjustments to drive growth and operational efficiency. David Dannemiller engages with local stakeholders to promote the bank's services and enhance its market position. Through the effective management of regional resources, the Regional President supports the bank's commitment to regional economic development. Ultimately, Dannemiller drives the success of the bank's operations within the territory, ensuring that all business units contribute to the institution's overall financial objectives and strategic goals.

    David Cardell - Regional President

    David Cardell, the Regional President at First Financial Bank, manages the execution of corporate strategy and business development within the assigned regional market. Cardell oversees the performance of commercial and personal banking teams, ensuring that all services align with the bank's standards for quality and accessibility. By analyzing regional market trends and competitive dynamics, the Regional President identifies new avenues for loan growth and treasury management expansion. This role involves leading regional initiatives that support the bank's digital and branch-based service models. David Cardell collaborates with other regional leaders to share best practices and optimize operational workflows across the organization. Through the active management of client relationships and community engagement, the Regional President strengthens the bank's reputation as a reliable financial partner. Ultimately, Cardell drives regional revenue and ensures that the bank's services effectively address the financial needs of individuals and businesses, contributing to the institution's long-term stability and growth.

    Niki Pilotte - Executive Vice President & Chief Information Officer

    Niki Pilotte, the Executive Vice President & Chief Information Officer at First Financial Bank, architects the digital infrastructure and technology roadmap for the entire enterprise. Pilotte oversees the development of secure digital banking channels, ensuring that customers across the Midwest experience seamless access to personal and business banking services. By integrating advanced cybersecurity protocols, the Executive Vice President & Chief Information Officer protects sensitive financial data and maintains system integrity. This role involves leading cross-functional teams to implement innovative fintech solutions that enhance the efficiency of commercial lending and treasury management. Niki Pilotte collaborates with other C-suite leaders to align technological investments with the bank's long-term growth objectives. Through the modernization of core banking systems, the Executive Vice President & Chief Information Officer drives operational agility and improves the overall customer experience. Ultimately, Pilotte ensures that the bank remains at the forefront of digital banking, supporting the institution's competitive position in the regional market.

    Explore Leadership Teams in Banking

    Frequently Asked Questions Regarding First Financial Bank Top Executives and Leadership Team

    Who leads First Financial Bank?
    First Financial Bank is led by Kyle Goodwin (Chief Executive Officer & President), along with executives such as Jamie Anderson (Chief Financial Officer) and Paul Cloutier (Senior Vice President - Finance and Chief Financial Officer).
    Who is part of First Financial Bank’s executive team?
    The executive team of First Financial Bank includes leaders such as Kyle Goodwin (Chief Executive Officer & President), Jamie Anderson (Chief Financial Officer), Paul Cloutier (Senior Vice President - Finance and Chief Financial Officer) and other senior executives.
    How many executives does First Financial Bank have?
    First Financial Bank has 10 executives leading key business areas.
    What roles are included in First Financial Bank’s leadership team?
    The leadership team of First Financial Bank includes roles such as Chief Executive Officer & President, Chief Financial Officer, Senior Vice President - Finance and Chief Financial Officer, Market President, Wealth Regional Market President.