First Financial Bank Executive and Leadership Team

September, 2026

Leadership Overview

First Financial Bank has 10 executives leading key functions including corporate strategy, financial oversight, wealth management, retail banking, and commercial lending.

Focused on delivering comprehensive financial solutions, First Financial Bank empowers individuals and businesses across the Midwest through a robust network of branch and digital banking channels.

Leadership Roles at First Financial Bank

  • Chief Executive Officer & President - Kyle Goodwin
  • Chief Financial Officer - Jamie Anderson
  • Wealth Regional Market President - Matthew Malafa
  • President, Retail Market Harrisburg - Zac Price
  • President, Market County (Senior Lender) - Mills Shallene
  • Regional President - David Cardell
  • Regional President, Market - Kirk Reis
  • Commercial Market President - Krista Dobronos
  • President, Market (Butler & Warren) - Jeff Judd
  • Regional President, Commercial (Cincinnati) - Jacob Holbrook
  • Kyle Goodwin - Chief Executive Officer & President

    Kyle Goodwin, the Chief Executive Officer & President at First Financial Bank, directs the overarching strategic vision and operational execution for the entire organization. Goodwin manages the alignment of personal banking, commercial lending, and treasury management services to ensure consistent growth across Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, and Illinois. By coordinating with the Board and senior leadership, the Chief Executive Officer & President drives initiatives that enhance market share and strengthen the institution's regional presence. This leadership role involves navigating complex regulatory environments while maintaining a focus on customer-centric digital transformation. Kyle Goodwin prioritizes long-term stability and shareholder value through disciplined capital allocation and risk management. Through the implementation of innovative financial products, the Chief Executive Officer & President secures the bank's competitive position in the evolving financial services landscape, ensuring that all regional operations remain responsive to the diverse needs of public-sector and private clients.

    Jamie Anderson - Chief Financial Officer

    Jamie Anderson, the Chief Financial Officer at First Financial Bank, oversees the financial health, reporting, and fiscal planning of the institution. Anderson directs the treasury management functions and capital structure to support the bank's extensive commercial lending and mortgage operations. By analyzing market trends across the Midwest, the Chief Financial Officer ensures that investment services and wealth management divisions maintain profitability and regulatory compliance. This role involves close collaboration with executive leadership to optimize balance sheet performance and liquidity management. Jamie Anderson monitors economic indicators to mitigate financial risk while identifying opportunities for expansion within the regional footprint. Through rigorous financial oversight, the Chief Financial Officer maintains the integrity of the bank's fiscal reporting and supports the strategic objectives of the organization. Anderson provides the necessary data-driven insights to guide corporate decision-making, ensuring that the bank remains a stable and reliable partner for all customers.
    Jamie Anderson

    Matthew Malafa - Wealth Regional Market President

    Matthew Malafa, the Wealth Regional Market President at First Financial Bank, directs the delivery of specialized investment services and wealth management solutions to high-net-worth individuals and institutional clients. Malafa oversees the regional strategy for asset growth and client retention, ensuring that wealth management offerings align with the broader commercial banking goals of the institution. By coordinating with regional teams, the Wealth Regional Market President expands the bank's footprint in key markets across the Midwest. This leadership role involves developing tailored financial plans that address complex estate, retirement, and investment needs. Matthew Malafa drives the integration of wealth services with personal and business banking channels to provide a seamless client experience. Through proactive market engagement, the Wealth Regional Market President strengthens the bank's reputation as a premier provider of financial advisory services, ultimately supporting the long-term financial success of the diverse client base served by the organization.

    Zac Price - President, Retail Market Harrisburg

    Zac Price, the President, Retail Market Harrisburg at First Financial Bank, directs all retail banking operations and customer service initiatives within the designated market area. Price oversees the branch network, ensuring that personal banking services, mortgage lending, and deposit products meet the specific needs of the local community. By managing branch performance and staff development, the President, Retail Market Harrisburg drives operational efficiency and customer satisfaction. This role involves executing corporate strategies at the local level to increase market penetration and brand loyalty. Zac Price coordinates with regional leadership to ensure that retail offerings remain competitive and accessible through both physical and digital channels. Through a focus on community engagement and service excellence, the President, Retail Market Harrisburg supports the bank's mission to provide comprehensive financial solutions. Price maintains a strong emphasis on operational standards, ensuring that every customer interaction reflects the core values and professional commitment of the institution.
    Zac Price

    Mills Shallene - President, Market County (Senior Lender)

    Mills Shallene, the President, Market County (Senior Lender) at First Financial Bank, directs the commercial lending activities and credit portfolio management within the assigned county market. Shallene oversees the underwriting process and relationship management for business clients, ensuring that lending practices align with the bank's risk appetite and growth objectives. By evaluating complex commercial loan applications, the President, Market County (Senior Lender) facilitates capital access for local businesses and public-sector entities. This role involves building strong partnerships with corporate clients to support their expansion and operational needs. Mills Shallene collaborates with other regional leaders to ensure that commercial banking services are integrated with treasury management and other financial products. Through diligent credit analysis and market monitoring, the President, Market County (Senior Lender) maintains a high-quality loan portfolio. Shallene drives the bank's commercial success by providing tailored financing solutions that foster economic development and long-term business stability within the region.

    David Cardell - Regional President

    David Cardell, the Regional President at First Financial Bank, directs the overall business strategy and operational performance across a designated geographic region. Cardell oversees the integration of personal banking, commercial lending, and wealth management services to ensure a unified market approach. By managing regional teams and branch operations, the Regional President drives growth in deposits and loan volume while maintaining high standards of customer service. This role involves representing the bank in local business communities and fostering relationships with key stakeholders. David Cardell coordinates with executive leadership to implement corporate initiatives that enhance the bank's competitive position in the Midwest. Through strategic oversight of regional resources, the Regional President ensures that all banking channels operate efficiently and effectively. Cardell focuses on identifying market opportunities and addressing local economic challenges, ultimately supporting the bank's mission to provide comprehensive financial solutions to individuals, businesses, and public-sector customers.

    Kirk Reis - Regional President, Market

    Kirk Reis, the Regional President, Market at First Financial Bank, directs the expansion and management of banking services within the assigned market territory. Reis oversees the performance of retail and commercial banking teams, ensuring that the bank's diverse product suite meets the evolving needs of the local customer base. By analyzing regional market trends, the Regional President, Market identifies opportunities for cross-selling and service enhancement. This role involves leading local initiatives that promote the bank's brand and commitment to community financial health. Kirk Reis collaborates with other regional leaders to share best practices and optimize operational workflows across the branch network. Through a focus on relationship management and service quality, the Regional President, Market drives sustainable growth in both the personal and business banking segments. Reis ensures that all regional activities align with the bank's broader strategic goals, providing consistent and reliable financial support to the communities served by the institution.

    Krista Dobronos - Commercial Market President

    Krista Dobronos, the Commercial Market President at First Financial Bank, directs the commercial banking strategy and relationship management for business clients within the market. Dobronos oversees the delivery of treasury management, commercial lending, and specialized financial services to support the growth of local enterprises. By managing a team of commercial bankers, the Commercial Market President ensures that clients receive tailored solutions that address their unique operational and capital requirements. This role involves active engagement with the business community to identify new lending opportunities and strengthen existing partnerships. Krista Dobronos coordinates with other C-suite leaders to align commercial banking activities with the bank's overall risk and growth objectives. Through a focus on credit quality and client service, the Commercial Market President drives the expansion of the bank's commercial portfolio. Dobronos plays a vital role in supporting the economic vitality of the region by providing the financial tools necessary for business success.

    Jeff Judd - President, Market (Butler & Warren)

    Jeff Judd, the President, Market (Butler & Warren) at First Financial Bank, directs the retail and commercial banking operations within the Butler and Warren market areas. Judd oversees the branch network and business development efforts, ensuring that personal banking, mortgage lending, and commercial services are delivered effectively to the local population. By managing local staff and resources, the President, Market (Butler & Warren) drives customer acquisition and retention strategies. This role involves building strong community ties and representing the bank in local economic development initiatives. Jeff Judd coordinates with regional leadership to ensure that all banking channels meet the bank's high standards for service and compliance. Through a focus on operational excellence and market growth, the President, Market (Butler & Warren) supports the bank's mission to provide comprehensive financial solutions. Judd ensures that the bank remains a trusted partner for individuals and businesses, contributing to the overall success of the organization.

    Jacob Holbrook - Regional President, Commercial (Cincinnati)

    Jacob Holbrook, the Regional President, Commercial (Cincinnati) at First Financial Bank, directs the commercial banking operations and business development strategy within the Cincinnati market. Holbrook oversees the management of complex commercial lending portfolios and treasury management services for large business and public-sector clients. By leading a team of commercial bankers, the Regional President, Commercial (Cincinnati) ensures that the bank provides sophisticated financial solutions that support the growth and stability of the local economy. This role involves close collaboration with other regional leaders to align commercial activities with the bank's broader strategic objectives. Jacob Holbrook focuses on maintaining high credit standards while actively pursuing new business opportunities in the competitive Cincinnati market. Through a commitment to relationship-based banking, the Regional President, Commercial (Cincinnati) strengthens the bank's market position and supports the financial needs of the diverse client base. Holbrook ensures that all commercial operations reflect the bank's dedication to excellence and professional service.

    Explore Leadership Teams in Banking

    Frequently Asked Questions Regarding First Financial Bank Top Executives and Leadership Team

    Who leads First Financial Bank?
    First Financial Bank is led by Kyle Goodwin (Chief Executive Officer & President), along with executives such as Jamie Anderson (Chief Financial Officer) and Matthew Malafa (Wealth Regional Market President).
    Who is part of First Financial Bank’s executive team?
    The executive team of First Financial Bank includes leaders such as Kyle Goodwin (Chief Executive Officer & President), Jamie Anderson (Chief Financial Officer), Matthew Malafa (Wealth Regional Market President) and other senior executives.
    How many executives does First Financial Bank have?
    First Financial Bank has 10 executives leading key business areas.
    What roles are included in First Financial Bank’s leadership team?
    The leadership team of First Financial Bank includes roles such as Chief Executive Officer & President, Chief Financial Officer, Wealth Regional Market President, President, Retail Market Harrisburg, President, Market County (Senior Lender).