BankFirst Executive and Leadership Team

June, 2026

Leadership Overview

BankFirst has 11 executives leading key functions including strategy, finance, and regional operations.

Driven by a commitment to community, BankFirst focuses on delivering comprehensive financial solutions while prioritizing social responsibility and long-term stability.

Leadership Roles at BankFirst

  • Chairman & Chief Executive Officer - Jay Tindall
  • President, Chief Executive Officer - Robert Mills
  • President & Chief Executive Officer - Jolene Carroll
  • Chief Financial Officer - Thomas Higginbotham
  • Desoto County President - Kyle Mccoy
  • President, Laurel Community Bank - Jameson Buckley
  • President - Stephen Scarpulla
  • President - Sandy Collins
  • City President - Andrew Young
  • Petal Community Bank President - Jj Thoms
  • Jay Tindall - Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

    Jay Tindall, the Chairman & Chief Executive Officer at BankFirst, directs the overarching strategy and corporate governance. Tindall's leadership ensures the institution's commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction guides all operational decisions. This executive oversees the alignment of business objectives with the bank's core values of social responsibility and innovation. By setting the strategic vision, Jay Tindall drives the long-term stability and growth of BankFirst, fostering a positive workplace culture that supports employee development and community engagement. The Chairman & Chief Executive Officer's role is pivotal in maintaining the bank's strong market position and its dedication to the financial well-being of the communities served. Tindall's executive oversight ensures that all departments operate cohesively towards achieving institutional goals and upholding the bank's reputation for integrity and service.

    Robert Mills - President, Chief Executive Officer

    Robert Mills, the President, Chief Executive Officer at BankFirst, executes the strategic initiatives established by the board and leadership team. Mills's focus centers on driving operational efficiency and enhancing customer satisfaction across all banking products and services. This executive champions the bank's commitment to social responsibility and innovation, ensuring these principles are integrated into daily operations. By leading the executive team, Robert Mills cultivates a dynamic workplace culture that empowers employees and supports community growth. The President, Chief Executive Officer's responsibilities include fostering long-term stability and financial well-being for the bank and its stakeholders. Mills actively guides the institution's expansion and service delivery, ensuring BankFirst remains a trusted financial partner. This leadership position is critical for translating corporate vision into tangible results and maintaining the bank's competitive edge in the financial sector.

    Jolene Carroll - President & Chief Executive Officer

    Jolene Carroll, the President & Chief Executive Officer at BankFirst, spearheads the strategic direction and operational management of the institution. Carroll's leadership emphasizes a deep commitment to customer satisfaction and community focus, ensuring that BankFirst's services meet diverse client needs. This executive drives the bank's dedication to innovation and social responsibility, integrating these values into the core business strategy. By fostering a positive and productive workplace, Jolene Carroll supports employee development and enhances the bank's overall performance. The President & Chief Executive Officer's role is crucial for maintaining long-term financial stability and promoting the economic health of the communities BankFirst serves. Carroll's executive guidance ensures the bank's continued growth and its reputation for excellence. This leadership position is central to upholding the institution's mission and achieving its ambitious objectives in the financial services landscape.

    Thomas Higginbotham - Chief Financial Officer

    Thomas Higginbotham, the Chief Financial Officer at BankFirst, manages the institution's financial health and strategic fiscal planning. Higginbotham oversees all financial operations, including accounting, budgeting, and financial reporting, ensuring compliance with regulatory standards and driving fiscal responsibility. This executive plays a key role in maintaining the bank's long-term stability and profitability through prudent financial management. By analyzing market trends and economic conditions, Thomas Higginbotham provides critical insights to support strategic decision-making across the organization. The Chief Financial Officer's leadership ensures that BankFirst's financial resources are allocated effectively to support growth initiatives and community development programs. Higginbotham's expertise is vital in safeguarding the bank's assets and optimizing its financial performance, reinforcing its commitment to customer satisfaction and operational excellence.
    Thomas Higginbotham

    Kyle Mccoy - Desoto County President

    Kyle Mccoy, the Desoto County President at BankFirst, leads regional operations and business development within the Desoto County market. Mccoy is responsible for implementing the bank's community-focused strategy, ensuring exceptional customer service and satisfaction in the region. This executive drives local engagement, fostering strong relationships with clients and community stakeholders to support economic growth. By overseeing regional banking activities, Kyle Mccoy ensures alignment with BankFirst's broader mission of social responsibility and innovation. The Desoto County President's role is critical in expanding the bank's presence and impact within the local community, promoting financial well-being. Mccoy's leadership ensures that the Desoto County operations contribute significantly to the bank's overall stability and success, reinforcing its commitment to serving its customers effectively.

    Jameson Buckley - President, Laurel Community Bank

    Jameson Buckley, the President, Laurel Community Bank at BankFirst, directs the strategic operations and community engagement for the Laurel branch. Buckley is dedicated to upholding BankFirst's commitment to customer satisfaction and providing a comprehensive range of banking services tailored to the local market. This executive champions the bank's principles of social responsibility and innovation, ensuring these values are reflected in the branch's activities. By fostering a supportive workplace, Jameson Buckley empowers the Laurel team to deliver exceptional service and contribute to community financial well-being. The President, Laurel Community Bank's leadership is instrumental in strengthening the bank's local presence and ensuring long-term stability. Buckley's focus on regional growth and client relationships solidifies BankFirst's position as a trusted financial partner in the Laurel area.

    Stephen Scarpulla - President

    Stephen Scarpulla, the President at BankFirst, oversees key operational functions and strategic initiatives across designated market areas. Scarpulla's leadership focuses on enhancing service delivery and ensuring customer satisfaction aligns with the bank's core values. This executive drives the implementation of innovative banking solutions and reinforces the commitment to social responsibility within operational frameworks. By cultivating a high-performance culture, Stephen Scarpulla supports employee development and contributes to the bank's long-term stability. The President's role is vital in expanding BankFirst's reach and impact, promoting financial well-being within the communities served. Scarpulla's strategic oversight ensures operational efficiency and strengthens the bank's reputation for excellence and reliability in the financial sector.
    Stephen Scarpulla

    Sandy Collins - President

    Sandy Collins, the President at BankFirst, directs significant operational segments and strategic growth initiatives. Collins is committed to advancing customer satisfaction through the delivery of robust banking products and services. This executive champions the bank's dedication to social responsibility and innovation, integrating these principles into regional business strategies. By fostering a collaborative environment, Sandy Collins empowers teams to achieve excellence and contribute to community financial health. The President's leadership is crucial for ensuring the long-term stability and success of BankFirst's operations in their designated markets. Collins's focus on strategic execution and client relationships reinforces the bank's mission and its role as a vital community financial institution.

    Andrew Young - City President

    Andrew Young, the City President at BankFirst, leads the strategic direction and operational execution within the city market. Young is responsible for driving customer satisfaction and ensuring the delivery of comprehensive banking solutions that meet local needs. This executive champions BankFirst's commitment to social responsibility and innovation, fostering strong community ties and economic development. By overseeing city-specific operations, Andrew Young ensures alignment with the bank's overarching goals of long-term stability and financial well-being for clients. The City President's role is critical in expanding the bank's influence and reinforcing its reputation for excellence. Young's leadership cultivates a positive workplace culture and enhances the bank's contribution to the urban economic landscape.

    Jj Thoms - Petal Community Bank President

    Jj Thoms, the Petal Community Bank President at BankFirst, manages the strategic operations and community outreach for the Petal region. Thoms is dedicated to enhancing customer satisfaction by providing tailored banking products and services that support local economic growth. This executive drives the bank's commitment to social responsibility and innovation, ensuring these values guide all regional initiatives. By fostering a client-centric approach, Jj Thoms strengthens relationships within the community and promotes financial well-being. The Petal Community Bank President's leadership is essential for maintaining the bank's long-term stability and its reputation for exceptional service. Thoms's focus on local market dynamics ensures BankFirst remains a trusted financial partner in Petal.

    Explore Leadership Teams in Banking

    Frequently Asked Questions Regarding BankFirst Top Executives and Leadership Team

    Who leads BankFirst?
    BankFirst is led by Jay Tindall (Chairman & Chief Executive Officer), along with executives such as Robert Mills (President, Chief Executive Officer) and Jolene Carroll (President & Chief Executive Officer).
    Who is part of BankFirst’s executive team?
    The executive team of BankFirst includes leaders such as Jay Tindall (Chairman & Chief Executive Officer), Robert Mills (President, Chief Executive Officer), Jolene Carroll (President & Chief Executive Officer) and other senior executives.
    How many executives does BankFirst have?
    BankFirst has 10 executives leading key business areas.
    What roles are included in BankFirst’s leadership team?
    The leadership team of BankFirst includes roles such as Chairman & Chief Executive Officer, President, Chief Executive Officer, President & Chief Executive Officer, Chief Financial Officer, Desoto County President.