Community First Credit Union Executive and Leadership Team

July, 2026

Leadership Overview

Community First Credit Union has 5 executives leading key functions including strategy, information technology, operations, finance, and human resources.

Driven by a commitment to member well-being, Community First Credit Union operates as a financial cooperative, delivering comprehensive banking, investment, financial education, and insurance services across Northeast and East Central Wisconsin, fostering economic empowerment and community growth.

Leadership Roles at Community First Credit Union

  • President & Chief Executive Officer - Catherine Tierney
  • Chief Financial Officer - Molly Sullivan
  • Chief Operating Officer - John Peterson
  • Chief Information Officer - Jimmy S.
  • Chief Human Resources Officer - Lori Aic
  • Catherine Tierney - President & Chief Executive Officer

    Catherine Tierney, the President & Chief Executive Officer at Community First Credit Union, directs the overall strategic vision and operational execution for the financial cooperative. Tierney guides the organization's mission to serve Northeast and East Central Wisconsin through comprehensive financial services, including banking, investment, education, and insurance. Overseeing all executive functions, Catherine Tierney ensures alignment with the cooperative's member-centric philosophy and market position. This leadership role involves fostering innovation in financial products and services to meet evolving member needs and maintain a competitive edge within the regional finance sector. By championing strategic initiatives, Tierney drives sustainable growth and reinforces Community First Credit Union's commitment to community economic development and member prosperity.

    Molly Sullivan - Chief Financial Officer

    Molly Sullivan, the Chief Financial Officer at Community First Credit Union, manages the organization's financial health, planning, and reporting. Sullivan oversees all fiscal operations, including budgeting, forecasting, investment strategies, and financial risk management, ensuring the stability and profitability of the credit union. This role is pivotal in supporting the delivery of comprehensive financial services to members across Northeast and East Central Wisconsin. Molly Sullivan works closely with the President & CEO and other executives to develop financial strategies that align with the cooperative's long-term goals and regulatory requirements. The Chief Financial Officer's expertise ensures prudent financial stewardship, enabling Community First Credit Union to provide competitive banking, investment, and insurance products while maintaining a strong capital position.

    John Peterson - Chief Operating Officer

    John Peterson, the Chief Operating Officer at Community First Credit Union, directs the day-to-day operational activities and service delivery across all branches and departments. Peterson oversees the efficient execution of banking, investment, financial education, and insurance services, ensuring seamless member experiences throughout Northeast and East Central Wisconsin. This leadership position involves optimizing internal processes, managing operational risks, and driving service excellence to uphold the cooperative's commitment to its members. John Peterson collaborates with other executives to implement strategic initiatives that enhance operational scalability and member satisfaction. The Chief Operating Officer's responsibilities include ensuring regulatory compliance and fostering a culture of continuous improvement within the operational framework of Community First Credit Union.

    Jimmy S. - Chief Information Officer

    Jimmy S., the Chief Information Officer at Community First Credit Union, architects and manages the organization's technology infrastructure and digital strategy. S. oversees the implementation and maintenance of secure, efficient information systems that support banking, investment, financial education, and insurance services across Northeast and East Central Wisconsin. This critical role involves ensuring the integrity and accessibility of member data while driving technological advancements to enhance member experience and operational efficiency. Jimmy S. leads the IT department in developing robust cybersecurity measures and exploring innovative digital solutions that align with Community First Credit Union's cooperative model. The Chief Information Officer's focus remains on leveraging technology to support the credit union's mission and expand its reach within the financial services landscape.

    Lori Aic - Chief Human Resources Officer

    Lori Aic, the Chief Human Resources Officer at Community First Credit Union, leads all human capital strategies and initiatives to support the organization's mission and workforce. Aic oversees talent acquisition, employee development, compensation and benefits, and fosters a positive and productive work environment for staff serving Northeast and East Central Wisconsin. This role is crucial in attracting and retaining skilled professionals who deliver exceptional banking, investment, financial education, and insurance services. Lori Aic ensures HR policies align with the cooperative's values and regulatory standards, promoting employee engagement and organizational effectiveness. The Chief Human Resources Officer's strategic direction cultivates a culture that empowers employees and drives the success of Community First Credit Union.

    Explore Leadership Teams in Banking

    Frequently Asked Questions Regarding Community First Credit Union Top Executives and Leadership Team

    Who leads Community First Credit Union?
    Community First Credit Union is led by Catherine Tierney (President & Chief Executive Officer), along with executives such as Molly Sullivan (Chief Financial Officer) and John Peterson (Chief Operating Officer).
    Who is part of Community First Credit Union’s executive team?
    The executive team of Community First Credit Union includes leaders such as Catherine Tierney (President & Chief Executive Officer), Molly Sullivan (Chief Financial Officer), John Peterson (Chief Operating Officer) and other senior executives.
    How many executives does Community First Credit Union have?
    Community First Credit Union has 5 executives leading key business areas.
    What roles are included in Community First Credit Union’s leadership team?
    The leadership team of Community First Credit Union includes roles such as President & Chief Executive Officer, Chief Financial Officer, Chief Operating Officer, Chief Information Officer, Chief Human Resources Officer.