CareSource Executive and Leadership Team

November, 2026

Leadership Overview

CareSource has 10 executives leading key functions including strategy, information technology, financial oversight, market operations, and human resources.

Committed to expanding access to quality health insurance, CareSource delivers integrated health plans designed to simplify complex care management for diverse populations across the United States.

Leadership Roles at CareSource

  • President & Chief Executive Officer - Erhardt Preitauer
  • Chief Executive Officer, Market (Nevada) - Jayme Puu
  • Chief Financial Officer, Market - Michael Tegler
  • Vice President, Chief Financial Officer - Health Plans - Andrea Watroba
  • Vice President, Chief Financial Officer of Health Plans - Enver Karadayi
  • Chief Operating Officer & Vice President, Market Operations - Dwayne Flowers
  • Chief Information Officer - Devon Valencia
  • Chief Technology Officer - Mike Dimond
  • Vice President, Chief of Staff - Wisconsin Market - Brian Gartner
  • Chief Human Resources Officer - Jennifer Dougherty
  • Erhardt Preitauer - President & Chief Executive Officer

    Erhardt Preitauer, the President & Chief Executive Officer at CareSource, directs the overarching strategic vision for the organization. Overseeing the delivery of Medicaid, Medicare, and Marketplace insurance plans, the President & Chief Executive Officer ensures alignment between corporate objectives and the needs of low-income individuals, families, and elderly adults. This leadership role involves navigating complex regulatory environments while driving growth across regional markets. By fostering partnerships with health care providers, Erhardt Preitauer strengthens the integrated health model that defines the company. The President & Chief Executive Officer maintains a focus on operational excellence to ensure that members receive comprehensive support. Through consistent evaluation of market trends, the executive secures the long-term sustainability of health insurance offerings. Ultimately, the President & Chief Executive Officer champions initiatives that simplify health care management for vulnerable populations, ensuring that the organization remains a leader in the insurance industry.
    Erhardt Preitauer

    Jayme Puu - Chief Executive Officer, Market (Nevada)

    Jayme Puu, the Chief Executive Officer, Market (Nevada) at CareSource, directs all regional operations and strategic initiatives within the Nevada market. Overseeing the implementation of Medicaid and Marketplace plans, the Chief Executive Officer, Market (Nevada) ensures that local members receive tailored health care support. This leadership role involves building relationships with regional providers and community stakeholders to expand the reach of the organization. By adapting corporate strategies to the specific needs of the Nevada population, Jayme Puu drives growth and improves health outcomes. The Chief Executive Officer, Market (Nevada) collaborates with the broader executive team to ensure consistency in service quality across all regions. Through effective management of local resources, the executive enhances the accessibility of health insurance for low-income individuals and families. Ultimately, the Chief Executive Officer, Market (Nevada) strengthens the company's market position by delivering localized solutions that simplify the management of health care needs.
    Jayme Puu

    Michael Tegler - Chief Financial Officer, Market

    Michael Tegler, the Chief Financial Officer, Market at CareSource, manages the fiscal health and budgetary planning for specific regional operations. Overseeing revenue cycle management and cost-containment strategies, the Chief Financial Officer, Market ensures that insurance plans remain financially viable while serving low-income populations. This leadership role involves analyzing market-specific data to allocate resources effectively across diverse demographics. By monitoring financial performance, Michael Tegler supports the expansion of Medicaid and Marketplace options in key territories. The Chief Financial Officer, Market collaborates with executive leadership to balance growth objectives with the necessity of providing affordable care. Through rigorous financial modeling, the executive identifies opportunities for operational efficiency. Ultimately, the Chief Financial Officer, Market maintains the fiscal stability required to support the organization's mission, ensuring that resources are directed toward improving health outcomes for members and providing consistent support for health care providers.
    Michael Tegler

    Andrea Watroba - Vice President, Chief Financial Officer - Health Plans

    Andrea Watroba, the Vice President, Chief Financial Officer - Health Plans at CareSource, oversees the financial strategy for the company's core insurance product lines. Managing the underwriting and actuarial functions, the Vice President, Chief Financial Officer - Health Plans ensures that health plans are priced accurately to reflect the needs of members. This leadership role involves coordinating with internal teams to maintain compliance with state and federal insurance regulations. By analyzing claims data and utilization patterns, Andrea Watroba drives improvements in the cost-effectiveness of health care delivery. The Vice President, Chief Financial Officer - Health Plans works to ensure that financial resources are aligned with the goal of providing comprehensive support to families and individuals. Through strategic financial planning, the executive supports the long-term sustainability of the organization's health insurance offerings. Ultimately, the Vice President, Chief Financial Officer - Health Plans secures the financial foundation necessary to deliver high-quality care across all markets.
    Andrea Watroba

    Enver Karadayi - Vice President, Chief Financial Officer of Health Plans

    Enver Karadayi, the Vice President, Chief Financial Officer of Health Plans at CareSource, directs the financial planning and analysis for the organization's health insurance portfolio. Overseeing the budgeting process for health plan operations, the Vice President, Chief Financial Officer of Health Plans ensures that resources are allocated to maximize member benefits. This leadership role involves monitoring the financial performance of various insurance products, including Medicaid and Marketplace options. By identifying trends in health care spending, Enver Karadayi supports the development of cost-effective care models. The Vice President, Chief Financial Officer of Health Plans collaborates with other financial leaders to ensure the overall fiscal health of the company. Through strategic oversight of financial operations, the executive enables the organization to continue providing comprehensive support to vulnerable populations. Ultimately, the Vice President, Chief Financial Officer of Health Plans maintains the financial discipline required to sustain the company's mission of simplifying health care management for all members.

    Dwayne Flowers - Chief Operating Officer & Vice President, Market Operations

    Dwayne Flowers, the Chief Operating Officer & Vice President, Market Operations at CareSource, manages the day-to-day execution of health plan delivery. Overseeing the operational workflows that support members and providers, the Chief Operating Officer & Vice President, Market Operations ensures that service standards are met consistently. This leadership role involves streamlining processes to improve the efficiency of Medicaid and Medicare plan administration. By coordinating across departments, Dwayne Flowers drives the successful implementation of operational strategies in various markets. The Chief Operating Officer & Vice President, Market Operations works to remove barriers to care, ensuring that members have seamless access to resources. Through the optimization of internal systems, the executive supports the organization's mission of simplifying health care management. Ultimately, the Chief Operating Officer & Vice President, Market Operations maintains the operational rigor necessary to provide comprehensive support to diverse populations, ensuring that the company remains responsive to the needs of members and providers.

    Devon Valencia - Chief Information Officer

    Devon Valencia, the Chief Information Officer at CareSource, architects the digital infrastructure necessary to support complex health insurance operations. Overseeing data security and information systems, the Chief Information Officer ensures that member records and provider networks remain accessible and protected. This leadership role involves implementing advanced analytics to improve health outcomes for children, pregnant women, and people with disabilities. By modernizing internal platforms, Devon Valencia drives efficiency across the organization, allowing for seamless integration of health plans. The Chief Information Officer collaborates with other C-suite leaders to align technological investments with the broader mission of simplifying health care management. Through the deployment of scalable software solutions, the executive supports the rapid expansion of digital services. Ultimately, the Chief Information Officer maintains the integrity of the information ecosystem, providing the foundation for high-quality member support and provider assistance across all regional markets.
    Devon Valencia

    Mike Dimond - Chief Technology Officer

    Mike Dimond, the Chief Technology Officer at CareSource, drives the innovation roadmap for the company's technical product suite. Overseeing the development of member-facing applications and provider portals, the Chief Technology Officer ensures that digital tools facilitate easier navigation of insurance benefits. This leadership role involves evaluating emerging technologies to enhance the delivery of Medicaid and Medicare services. By optimizing the technical architecture, Mike Dimond improves the speed and reliability of health plan administration. The Chief Technology Officer works closely with the information technology department to ensure that all systems support the company's commitment to comprehensive care. Through the implementation of robust cloud solutions, the executive enables greater agility in responding to market demands. Ultimately, the Chief Technology Officer secures the technological future of the organization, ensuring that members and providers have access to efficient, user-friendly resources that simplify the management of health care needs.

    Brian Gartner - Vice President, Chief of Staff - Wisconsin Market

    Brian Gartner, the Vice President, Chief of Staff - Wisconsin Market at CareSource, coordinates strategic initiatives and operational priorities within the Wisconsin region. Overseeing the alignment of local market goals with the broader corporate mission, the Vice President, Chief of Staff - Wisconsin Market ensures that health plans are effectively delivered to members. This leadership role involves facilitating communication between regional teams and executive leadership to drive performance. By managing key projects and initiatives, Brian Gartner supports the expansion of Medicaid and Medicare services in the area. The Vice President, Chief of Staff - Wisconsin Market works to ensure that resources are utilized efficiently to improve health outcomes for families and individuals. Through the integration of local insights, the executive enhances the company's ability to provide comprehensive support. Ultimately, the Vice President, Chief of Staff - Wisconsin Market secures the success of regional operations by fostering collaboration and maintaining a focus on the organization's core objectives.

    Jennifer Dougherty - Chief Human Resources Officer

    Jennifer Dougherty, the Chief Human Resources Officer at CareSource, directs the talent strategy and organizational culture for the company. Overseeing recruitment, employee development, and workforce planning, the Chief Human Resources Officer ensures that the organization attracts and retains the talent necessary to support health insurance operations. This leadership role involves fostering an inclusive environment that aligns with the company's mission of serving diverse populations. By implementing training programs, Jennifer Dougherty empowers employees to provide high-quality support to members and providers. The Chief Human Resources Officer collaborates with executive leadership to ensure that human capital strategies support the company's growth and operational goals. Through the development of performance management systems, the executive drives accountability and excellence across all departments. Ultimately, the Chief Human Resources Officer maintains the organizational health required to deliver comprehensive care, ensuring that the workforce remains dedicated to simplifying health care management for all members.
    Jennifer Dougherty

    Explore Leadership Teams in Insurance

    Frequently Asked Questions Regarding CareSource Top Executives and Leadership Team

    Who leads CareSource?
    CareSource is led by Erhardt Preitauer (President & Chief Executive Officer), along with executives such as Jayme Puu (Chief Executive Officer, Market (Nevada)) and Michael Tegler (Chief Financial Officer, Market).
    Who is part of CareSource’s executive team?
    The executive team of CareSource includes leaders such as Erhardt Preitauer (President & Chief Executive Officer), Jayme Puu (Chief Executive Officer, Market (Nevada)), Michael Tegler (Chief Financial Officer, Market) and other senior executives.
    How many executives does CareSource have?
    CareSource has 10 executives leading key business areas.
    What roles are included in CareSource’s leadership team?
    The leadership team of CareSource includes roles such as President & Chief Executive Officer, Chief Executive Officer, Market (Nevada), Chief Financial Officer, Market, Vice President, Chief Financial Officer - Health Plans, Vice President, Chief Financial Officer of Health Plans.