www.skyraider.org/skyassn/cnn/nyt280698.htm -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 6/28/1998
Last Visited: 1/17/2002
Dr. Allan Young, an anthropologist at McGill University in Montreal who wrote "The Harmony of Illusions: Inventing Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder" (Princeton University Press, 1996) said he was "very, very dubious" about the claims on the CNN program.Young spent two years at a VA hospital in the United States studying Vietnam veterans claiming emotional disabilities.
He has been fascinated by new narratives emerging as Vietnam fades in memory, he said.While many patients obviously had arduous combat experiences, a growing number of cases "involve a veteran who was not in Vietnam -- or if he was in Vietnam, he was not in combat," he said.In group therapy sessions, these patients assemble shards of others' claims and even snippets of movies into fantasies of personal combat experiences, usually of heroic actions or harrowing peril.
But more intriguing, he said, is a small subdivision of that group -- men who falsely implicate themselves in atrocities."They make up war crimes for themselves," Young said.
Why would anybody do that?
Young said that a motive could involve a quest for sympathy, for bigger disability payments or something far simpler.
"Guaranteed attention," he said.