www.reformed.com/pub/music.htm -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 1/28/2006
Last Visited: 3/5/2007
Williamson writes: "The whole system of ceremonial worship served as a 'shadow of heavenly things' (Heb. 8:5).
...
The New Testament does not authorize the use of musical instruments in Christian public worship.87 G. I. Williamson writes: "The fundamentalists speak of rebuilding the temple in Jerusalem, and thus take seriously the fact that this Old Testament worship was commanded by God.
...
Regarding Psalm 150:3, Calvin writes: "I do not insist upon the words in Hebrew signifying the musical instrument [in other words they may just be poetic metaphors exhorting believers to great praise]; only let the reader remember that sundry different kinds are here mentioned, which were in use under the legal economy, the more forcibly to teach the children of God that they cannot apply themselves too diligently to the praises of God."90
...
Too many church leaders are content to defend the status quo. (But, a non-reforming church is a deforming one.) When confronted with the biblical evidence regarding the use of musical instruments in the public worship (also, unauthorized holy days and exclusive psalmody) the response usually is: "I don't want to hear it.Who cares?That's interesting but I love the sound of musical instruments in worship.This issue could be divisive, so just drop it".These answers reveal an unscriptural, anti-Reformed attitude."Is it not evident,painfully evident,that they are really arrogant words? 'Who cares what God wants,' such people say in effect: 'So long as I have what I want!I am the important one!' This is the very antithesis of true religion."108 Human traditions have the ability to pull the heart strings.
...
We have brought into our churches a certain operose and theatrical music; such a confused, disorderly chattering of some words, as I hardly think was ever heard in any of the Grecian or Roman theatres.
...
But the promise made, that "Wheresoever two or three be gathered together in my name, there shall I be in the midst of them," condemneth all such as condemneth the congregation gathered in his name.But mark well the word "gathered;" I mean not to hear piping, singing, or playing; nor to patter upon beads, or books whereof they have no understanding; not to commit idolatry, honoring that for God which is no God indeed.For with such will I neither join myself in common prayer, nor in receiving external sacraments; for in so doing I should affirm their superstition and abominable idolatry, which I, by God's grace, never will do, neither counsel others to do, to the end. ,John Knox (Reformer, Scotland), A Declaration of the True Nature and Object of Prayer (1554).
...
I. The instrumental musick used in the old church of Israel was an institution of God: it was (2 Chron.29:25) the commandment of the Lord "by the prophets."And the instruments are called "God's instruments," (1 Chron.16:42), and "instruments of the Lord," (2 Chron.7:6).Now, there is not one word of institution in the New Testament for instrumental musick in the worship of God.And because the holy God rejects all He does not command in His worship, He now therefore in effect says unto us, "I will not hear the melody of thy Organs."
...
So to those who have no real devotion or spirituality in them, and whose animal nature flags under the oppression of church services, I think with Mr. G, that instrumental music would be not only a desideratum, but an essential prerequisite to fire up their souls to even animal devotion.But I presume, to all spiritual-minded Christians, such aids would be as a cowbell in a concert. ,Alexander Campbell (minister and co-founder of the Christian Church [i.e. Campbellites]), in The Millennial Harbinger (1851).
...
Lowell Mason [noted 19th -century hymn writer and worship leader in Alexander's congregation for four years] said to me t'other day: "I have been an organist all my life; yet if a congregation should say to me, 'Shall we have an organ?' I should scarcely dare to reply 'Yes.'" ,James W. Alexander (minister, Presbyterian Church, USA), "Letter to John Hall, dated New York, May, 1854," in Forty Years' Familiar Letters of James W. Alexander, D.D. (1860).
...
In the same name and by the same authority, that of the Lord Christ, I debar ministerially all impenitent violators of the second commandment; all who, while they professedly worship the true God, do not recognize and act upon the principle that God alone has the right to prescribe the institutes of his own worship;,who worship God by proxy, with choirs111 and organs.
...
Paul says, "I will sing with the spirit, and I will sing with the understanding also."An instrument has no spirit; it has no understanding.The human voice has conjoined with it both spirit and understanding.... God has drawn the line for us when he says, "I will sing with the spirit," not with the organ.
...
I.Williamson (minister, Orthodox Presbyterian Church), "Instrumental Music in Worship: Commanded or Not Commanded?," in The Biblical Doctrine of Worship (1974).
...
In another succinct statement, the Scottish reformer said: "I feared not to affirm, that of necessity it is, that such as hope for life everlasting avoid all superstition, vain religion, and idolatry.
...
Yet, it might have been more shocking to his Presbyterian readers if Mr. Frame simply had come out and said directly, "I oppose the teaching of the Westminster Confession in its description of the parts of worship."
...
In the Preface to the book, Frame claims, "In my view, the Westminster Confession is entirely right in its regulative principle,that true worship is limited to what God commands" (p. xiii). (Including drama, right?) Turning the page, we are assured, "My own theological commitment is Presbyterian; I subscribe enthusiastically to the Westminster Confession of Faith and Catechisms, and I trust that that commitment will be quite evident in this book" (pp. xiv-xv).Unfortunately, Frame's commitment to confessional Presbyterianism is precisely what is not apparent in the book.
Indeed, what Frame professes to give with one hand, he takes away with the other.In the Preface, he shows his true colors:
Presbyterian worship,based on the biblical "regulative principle," which I describe in these pages,was in its early days very restrictive, austere, and "minimalist."134 It excluded organs, choirs, hymn texts other than the Psalms, symbolism in the worship area, and religious holidays except for the Sabbath.135 Presbyterians in the "Covenanter" tradition, such as those in the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America and a few other denominations, still worship this way, but they are in that respect a small minority of conservative Presbyterians today.
...
I have talked to pastors, for instance, who are unwilling to go back to exclusive use of the Psalms in congregational singing, yet feel awkward about singing hymns.
...
And, if it be said, man's soul cannot be painted, but his body may, and yet that picture represents a man: I answer, it does so because he has but one nature; and what represents that, represents the person: But it is not so with Christ; his Godhead is not a distinct part of the human nature, as the soul of man is (which is necessarily supposed in every living man) but a distinct nature, only united with the manhood in that one person, Christ, who has no fellow: Therefore what represents him, must not represent a man only, but must represent Christ, Immanuel, God-man, otherwise it is not his image.
...
42 G. I. Williamson, On the Observance of Sacred Days (Havertown, ND: New Covenant Publication Society), pp.9-10.
...
56 G. I. Williamson, Instrumental Music in the Worship of God: Commanded or Not Commanded?, p. 5.
...
66 G. I. Williamson, Instrumental Music in the Worship of God: Commanded or Not Commanded?, pp.7-8.
...
67 John Calvin concurs: "I have no doubt that playing upon cymbals, touching the harp and the viol, and all that kind of music, which is so frequently mentioned in the Psalms, was a part of the education; that is to say, the puerile [i.e., immature] instruction of the law: I speak of the stated service of the temple.
...
For even now, if believers choose to cheer themselves with musical instruments, they should, I think, make it their object not to dissever their cheerfulness from the praises of God.
...
81 G. I. Williamson, Instrumental Worship in the Worship of God: Commanded or Not Commanded?, p. 11.