Taylor v. VUU Case -
[Cached Version]
Last Visited: 9/4/2009
At all times relevant to this appeal, Eugene Wells (Chief Wells)
served as the Department's Chief of Police.
In this position, Chief
Wells was responsible for the daily operation and administration of
...
Chief Wells had input with respect to significant personnel decisions,
although the ultimate decision making authority rested with the
Department Supervisor.
However, Chief Wells was authorized to
...
In April 1993, Wells rated Taylor's communication
skills as "marginal" in a written performance evaluation and encour-
aged her to improve in that area.
Wells rated Taylor's skills in all
...
munication skills, Wells allowed Taylor to serve on a regular basis as
...
November 1994, Chief Wells recommended to Department Supervi-
...
that Chief Wells assured her that she would be sent to the Police
Academy.
Nevertheless, Taylor claims that she was not sent to the
...
or Lieutenant Terry) of the Department: "I asked[Chief Wells] one
...
Furthermore, Corporal Harrell testified that Chief Wells had
...
Chief Wells rated Johnson as
...
In May 1994, Johnson sent a letter to Chief Wells expressing her
...
Johnson, Chief Wells then told her, "I don't know why you can't be
...
result of discriminatory animus held by Chief Wells toward women,
like Taylor, Johnson relies upon the exchange between Chief Wells
...
during her tenure with the Department, Chief Wells: (1) talked to her
in his office with the door shut; (2) told her she would be promoted
if she "did the right thing"; (3) told her she looked good in her uni-
form; and (4) touched her on her arm or shoulder when he spoke to
...
Wells once stated that he bet a certain unidentified woman had "good
...
Mr. Wells, Chief Wells.
...
refusing to admit evidence, over her objection, that Chief Wells once
stated that he bet a certain unidentified woman had"good pussy" and
...
Chief Wells, whom she alleges harbored discriminatory animus
...
Wells was instrumental in hiring Taylor in August 1992, and evalu-
...
Wells would have falsely rated Taylor as marginal in one category in
...
attend the Police Academy: "I asked [Chief Wells] one day was he
...
attitude toward women, because Chief Wells made the statement in
...
Chief Wells never sent any VUU officer to the Police Academy with
...
cretion in excluding evidence that Chief Wells once stated that he bet
a certain unidentified woman had "good pussy" and evidence that
Chief Wells called a female VUU employee named Angela Sheridan
...
Wells commented that he would never send a woman to the Police
...
relied upon Corporal Harrell's testimony that Chief Wells referred to
...
Johnson offered the evidence of Chief Wells' alleged"good pussy"
...
ing that Chief Wells failed to recommend her for promotion to the
...
evidence that was already before the jury on the issue of Chief Wells'
...
that Chief Wells stated he would never send a woman to the Police
...
ble, Johnson relied on her own testimony that Chief Wells touched
...
Chief Wells, she stated that she "enjoyed very much working under
...
employed by VUU of Chief Wells' "good pussy" comment or of his
...
abused its discretion in excluding evidence that Chief Wells once
stated that he bet a certain unidentified woman had"good pussy,"
(J.A. 187), and in excluding evidence that Chief Wells called a female
...
dence that Chief Wells solicited a prostitute in 1995, one year after John-
...
Mr. Wells, Chief Wells.