finance.tc-library.org/Content.asp?uid=1378 -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 10/5/2009
Last Visited: 10/5/2009
On Thursday, October 14, 2004, CFE presented testimony from expert witness Dr. Thomas Sobol.
Dr. Sobol was Commissioner of Education for the state of New York from 1987 to 1995 and, since then, has been a professor at Teachers College, Columbia University.
In his testimony Dr. Sobol was asked to compare the educational accountability proposals put before the special masters panel by plaintiffs and defendants.
Dr. Sobol characterized CFE's Sound Basic Education Task Force accountability proposal as "comprehensive and systemic, while he referred to the Zarb Commission's accountability recommendations, which the governor has endorsed, as "scattershot."
Dr. Sobol particularly praised CFE for its inclusiveness-both in the collaborative process by which it gathered expertise to develop the proposal and in the proposal itself, which calls for the meaningful engagement of parents, teachers, and others in citywide and school-level planning and decision making.
Dr. Sobol further testified that CFE's accountability proposal is an important complement to the state's current system, which is based on the Regents Learning Standards and the federal No Child Left Behind Act, because the proposal creates state and district accountability for the resources and the climate for learning that students need to succeed.
Finally, Dr. Sobol strongly denounced the governor's proposal for an "independent" office of educational accountability, saying that setting up another level of educational bureaucracy would "create confusion and invite mischief.
If the governor wants more political control over educational operations in the state, Dr. Sobol said, then he should seek it through legitimate means and with appropriate public debate of the issue-not through the "back door" in the remedy of a school-funding case.