Beaconsfield Gold - March 2003 Quarterly Report -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 3/1/2003
Last Visited: 8/23/2009
Joint Administrators (Michael Ryan and Tony Woodings of chartered accounting firm, Taylor Woodings, based in Perth, Western Australia) were appointed to Allstate on 8 June 2001 and a Receiver and Manager (Garry Trevor of Ferrier Hodgson, Perth office) was appointed to Beaconsfield Gold on 25 June 2001.
...
The updated BMJV budget for 1 January 2003 to 30 June 2003 and the BMJV forecasts for 1 July 2003 to 31 December 2003 (these documents would have been approved in December 2002 by the BMJV Operating Committee, consisting of the Allstate Administrator, Michael Ryan, as Chairman and the Receiver and Manager of Beaconsfield Gold, Garry Trevor).
...
The Executive Director of Beaconsfield Gold understands that during the afternoon of Thursday, 7 June 2001, Macquarie Bank representatives and Mr Michael Ryan of Taylor Woodings visited the Allstate head office in Sydney.
...
In a circular to the creditors of Allstate dated 5 March 2002, one of the Joint Administrators of Allstate, Mr Michael Ryan, outlined a proposal received from Macquarie Bank and called for a meeting on 19 March 2002 to vote on accepting the proposal.
...
Why the Allstate Administrators would be so wayward in the critical information they supplied to the creditors is not clear as one of the Joint Administrators, Mr Michael Ryan, is understood to be the current Chairman of the BMJV Operating Committee which approves the budgets for the BMJV.
...
The official minutes of the meeting also note that the Joint Administrator, Mr Michael Ryan, said the following: "The Bank does have other options available to it.
...
It is not clear why the Joint Administrator, Mr Michael Ryan, considered that Macquarie could vote on the resolution, given that Macquarie were clearly going to be advantaged if the resolution was passed.
...
A circular to the creditors and shareholders of Allstate was released to the ASX by the Allstate Joint Administrator, Mr Michael Ryan, on 29 October 2002.
This was the first communication the Allstate shareholders had received from the Joint Administrators since their appointment on 8 June 2001
One comment by Mr Michael Ryan in the circular was, in part: "........ at this stage, it appears that there is little, if any, equity in Allstate that will be available for its shareholders."The Allstate shareholders had never been advised or consulted about the Macquarie Bank proposal to divert the next $77.5 million of free cashflow from Allstate to Macquarie.
As the circular did not mention the figure of $77.5 million (it referred only to "..... the sale by Allstate to Macquarie Bank Limited of certain debts that were owing to Allstate by [its subsidiaries]"), the majority of Allstate shareholders probably still don't know what really happened to their company on 19 March 2002
Another comment by Mr Michael Ryan was, in part:"....... the challenge for the BMJV over the next 12 months will be for it to move from the current consolidation period of trading, during which the BMJV has largely traded cash flow neutral (after Capital Expenditure), to a period of significant and continuous cash surpluses so that meaningful debt reductions can be made."This comment, regarding the BMJV having been largely cash flow neutral, contradicted the Beaconsfield Gold published estimates of BMJV net cash flow, which had been based on the BMJV monthly accounts produced by Allstate as Manager of the BMJV.
In the September 2002 quarterly report for Beaconsfield Gold, the Executive Director referred to the comment by Mr Michael Ryan and noted that the Allstate Joint Administrator may have been confusing BMJV net cash flow with Allstate net cash flow.
...
Not only the Allstate Joint Administrator, Michael Ryan, may have been confusing BMJV net cash flow with Allstate net cash flow.
...
The minutes of a meeting of Allstate creditors held on 16 December 2002, chaired by one of the Joint Administrators of Allstate, Mr Michael Ryan, included the following: "...... a mediation was held on the Thursday and Friday prior to the meeting.
...
In the interest of estimating Beaconsfield Gold's position, consider a net settlement to Beaconsfield Gold of $5 million to $10 million occurring on 31 July 2003. (In a circular to Allstate creditors dated 5 March 2002, the Joint Administrator of Allstate, Mr Michael Ryan, estimated a gross range for Beaconsfield Gold and Allstate combined of $10 million to $40 million which equates to a gross settlement for Beaconsfield Gold of $4.8 million to $19.4 million.)