www.americantorture.com/labels/Torture.html -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 1/5/2008
Last Visited: 9/13/2009
Spencer Ackerman has looked at the possibility that former SERE psychologist James Mitchell wrote the report, and the conflict of interest that arises from having the interrogator/torturer write the report upon which the approach to the subject will be based.
...
While it's a reasonable guess that Mitchell wrote the evaluation, I'm going to proceed as if I don't know who wrote it.
...
Towards the end of the psychological evaluation, less its last redacted paragraphs, the author -- and it was an Agency or Agency contract psychologist, since only psychologists write these reports (and it was likely either James Mitchell or Bruce Jessen, who arrived in Thailand in July) -- notes the following, allowing that Zubaydah is "well-versed" in Al Qaeda resistance techniques (emphasis added):
...
Labels: Abu Zubaydah, Al Qaida, CIA, James Mitchell, Marcy Wheeler, Military Psychologists, Office of Legal Counsel, Torture, Waterboarding
...
In parts one and two of this series on the origins of the SERE torture program, we examined how unlikely it was that James Mitchell and Bruce Jessen, relying on entrepreneurial guile and chutzpah alone, convinced a passive Pentagon and CIA, eager to find some way to get terror intelligence, to buy into their "learned helplessness" interrogation paradigm.
...
It seems plausible that others were in on the scheme, and in part two, we examined the idea that Mitchell and Jessen's superior, Col.
...
David Ayers, head of Tate, Inc., was the other MJA shareholder, along with Joseph Matarazzo, yet another former president of the American Psychological Association who crossed Mitchell and Jessen's path.
...
Matarazzo, who Jane Mayer recently reported worked for the CIA, had been hired by Mitchell and Jessen years earlier, in 1996, along with other prominent U.S. psychologists -- Charles Speilberger, Richard Lazarus, and Albert Bandura -- for an internal review of SERE training procedures, according to a SERE internal document.
...
Nor should we consider this a conspiracy between only Aldrich, Mitchell and Jessen.
...
In this scenario, Mitchell and Jessen can best be understood as agents in the operation, and not brain trusters.
...
The chain of command for the torture program appears to have run from Bush-Cheney, to leaders of JSOC and their CIA supporters, to the "legendary" Roger Aldrich, and on down to his trusted men, Mitchell, Jessen, Baumgarten and others at Aldrich's agency, JPRA.
...
The main problem with analyses of the Mitchell-Jessen program thus far is the failure to plausibly link the top layers of the administration, which we know were involved in approving torture, to such lowly players as Mitchell and Jessen.
...
Whatever actually happened, whether Scott Shane, who wrote the recent New York Timesarticle on Mitchell and Jessen, is right, or my scenario, or some other, we must have investigations with real teeth to get to the truth, followed by prosecutions of those who were responsible for crimes of war, of crimes against humanity.
...
Labels: Bruce Jessen, James Mitchell, JPRA, military contractors, Roger Aldrich, SERE, Special Forces, Torture
...
This is essentially the way the story was presented in a 12 August New York Timesarticle by Scott Shane, leaving the question unanswered: how did Mitchell and Jessen get involved in constructing an offensive torture program to begin with?
...
The documentary record demonstrates that Mitchell and Jessen were not alone in proposing that military survival and resistance (SERE) psychologists and trainers be used to lead interrogations of the flood of prisoners in the new "war on terror."
...
How could Mitchell and Jessen be seen as the prime proponents for the program when in December 2001, according to released materials in the Senate Armed Services Committee's report on prisoner abuse, the Chief of Staff of the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA), Lt.
...
While the New York Times article makes almost no attempt to link the Mitchell-Jessen episode to the larger spread of torture throughout the U.S. armed forces, or to describe the actual role of the CIA in fostering it, Mitchell and Jessen's influence is assumed.
...
No doubt, Mitchell and Jessen will pursue just such a defense. (See the recent Joby Warrick/Peter Finn article in the Washington Post, which describes the persistent "permissions" for each torture interrogation secured by Abu Zubaydah's interrogators.)
...
He took Mitchell and Jessen and promoted them.
...
Labels: Bruce Jessen, Daniel Baumgartner, James Mitchell, JPRA, Roger Aldrich, Senate Armed Services Committee, SERE, Torture
...
In order to make these connections, we must first consider the established narrative thus far, exemplified by Scott Shane's new article on Mitchell and Jessen in the 12 August New York Times.
...
By all accounts, James Mitchell and John "Bruce" Jessen have a lot to answer for.
...
In Shane's version, an entrepreneurial James Mitchell "impressed" the CIA's Cofer Black and Jose Rodriguez, Jr. "by his combination of visceral toughness and psychological jargon.
...
Mitchell had developed a theory, so Shane explains, that a psychological doctrine called "learned helplessness" could be used to make resistant Al Qaeda prisoners comply with interrogator demands.
...
While more experienced interrogators criticized this view, somehow Mitchell prevailed.
...
Shane remarks that Mitchell met and fawned over Seligman, who was the originator of the "learned helplessness" theory.
...
But nothing is reported about Mitchell retailing his own theories on reverse-engineering SERE training at this event, and Seligman reports he knew nothing of what Mitchell was planning.
...
In fact, the entire connection between special operations forces and Mitchell and Jessen, or their parent SERE agency, is neglected in the article.
...
At the C.I.A. in December 2001, Dr. Mitchell's theories were attracting high-level attention.
Agency officials asked him to review a Qaeda manual, seized in England, that coached terrorist operatives to resist interrogations.
He contacted Dr. Jessen, and the two men wrote the first proposal to turn the enemy's brutal techniques - slaps, stress positions, sleep deprivation, wall-slamming and waterboarding - into an American interrogation program.
By the start of 2002, Dr. Mitchell was consulting with the C.I.A.'s Counterterrorist Center.... One person who heard some discussions said Dr. Mitchell gave the C.I.A. officials what they wanted to hear....
...
Then the C.I.A. team, including Dr. Mitchell, arrived.
This explanation of the origins of the torture program leaves a lot to be desired (and really offers nothing new).
How did Mitchell's "theories" come to the attention of the CIA?
Why did they give Mitchell the assignment of "reviewing" the so-called Al Qaeda manual, which had been in Western hands for at least six months?
...
Labels: Bruce Jessen, CIA, James Mitchell, Martin Seligman, New York Times, SERE, Torture
...
The spotlight has mainly fallen on the activities of former SERE psychologists James Mitchell and Bruce Jessen, who together spearheaded the implementation of a prisoner "exploitation plan" that became known later as "enhanced interrogation techniques," and included a number of torture techniques, including isolation, sleep deprivation, stress positions, sensory deprivation and overload, forced nudity, waterboarding, and much more.
...
Sometime in late 2001, former SERE psychologist and contractor wannabe, James Mitchell, had received a copy of a purported Al Qaeda manual, which included instructions on how to withstand interrogation.
According to an anonymous source who claims some knowledge of the individuals involved, and who has been credible on other matters pertaining to JPRA, Mitchell obtained the document from his superiors inside JPRA's Personnel Recovery Academy (PRA).
...
For those prone to speculate, the appearance of the Al Qaeda Resistance Manual in the hands of James Mitchell and the capture of al-Libi in mid-December 2001 seems awfully coincidental.)
...
Labels: Bruce Jessen, Iraq war, James Mitchell, JPRA, Lyle Koenig, Senate Armed Services Committee, SERE, Special Forces, Task Force 121, Thomas Moore, Torture