www.nwanews.com/adg/Sports/249868/ -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 1/18/2009
Last Visited: 1/18/2009
I asked Brad Miller, the AGFC's deer biologist, if a 4-point rule would accomplish anything that the 3-point rule does not.
He said that because deer have bigger antlers and body weights both in the Delta and on Crowley's Ridge, some yearling bucks are still vulnerable there.
"Looking at 2007-2008 harvest data from the Delta, about 11 percent of antlered bucks harvested that had five or more total points were yearlings," Miller said.
"If we change the antler point restriction to require at least four points on one side of a buck's rack, we're going to further reduce the harvest of yearling bucks."
Of course, a percentage of yearling bucks still will carry at least four points on one antler, so a 4-point rule would not protect them.
Nor does it seem excessively high for 11 percent of the kill to be yearlings.
Under a 4-point rule, Miller said that percentage might drop to about 4-5 percent.
The decision to implement such a rule, he added, is up to the public.
"People need to decide whether this is a proposal we should consider," Miller said.
My impression from hunters in eastern Arkansas is that most landowners and hunt clubs already follow a self-imposed 4- point rule.
Miller said that assessment is accurate, especially in southeast Arkansas.
I asked him if it was necessary to mandate through regulation what most people are already doing voluntarily.
"Again, that's one of those things the commissioners have to vote on, and the public has to give input on," Miller said.
"We had our public meetings a week ago.
Based on our public meetings in Jonesboro and Brinkley, written comments were primarily against going to a 4-point rule.
Generally, they were just against it."
Miller said 34 people attended the meeting in Jonesboro, and 24 attended the Brinkley meeting.
Only four people attended the Pine Bluff meeting.
You can also comment online via the AGFC's Web site.
Miller said the agency has gotten about 150 online comments, and he said more of those favor a 4-point rule.