Fantastic tales of sexual abuse: a history -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 5/4/2001
Last Visited: 11/14/2001
One of the worst stories is that of Kelly Michaels.Ceci and Bruck devote special attention to the questioning of children in the Michaels case.Freshly graduated from a small Catholic college near Pittsburgh , Michaels was arrested in 1986 , charged with sexually abusing dozens of children at the Wee Care daycare center in New Jersey.After a lengthy jury trial , Michaels was sentenced to forty-seven years in prison.Ceci and Bruck filed an amicus brief in her appeal.Signed by forty-six child psychologists , the brief argued that testimony had been elicited from children in a shocking manner by frightening and bullying them and through sexually explicit interviewing.
It is worth noting that in the Michaels case , as in the other daycare cases , the improbability of the entire scenario disturbed not judge , jury , or media.Michaels was accused of raping almost all the children in the daycare center with knives , forks , spoons , Lego blocks -all during regular school hours for a period of seven months.Audiotapes of the children's original testimony showed that some children testified their parents were present during these goings-on.One child asserted that the head teacher had walked in as Kelly was penetrating the children with assorted utensils , took the silverware , and put it in her briefcase.The prosecution disposed of such inconvenient testimony by explaining that these were rescue fantasies..
No member of the staff at Wee Care had noticed anything amiss in all those months and no child had complained to his parents.So , while , in his summing up , Judge William Harth adjured the jury to use your common sense , neither he nor the jury showed much of that vital commodity.Michaels had been imprisoned for five years before the appeals court threw out her conviction on the grounds that the children's testimony had been tainted by improper interviewing techniques.
As for the women with repressed memories who cut themselves off from their parents , even going so far as to sue them in civil or criminal court , many have recanted their accusations or reestablished ties without saying they were wrong.Many families remain permanently estranged.Many of the women convicted in the daycare or sex ring cases have by now been released ( the men are another story ).But the lives of all those involved were shattered , and it is hard to put Humpty Dumpty together again.