Business Times -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 8/15/2005
Last Visited: 8/15/2005
ECM Libra Securities analyst Bryan Lim attributed MAS' projected loss mainly to its vulnerability to fuel price increases and inability to cushion the impact due to high overhead costs.
He estimated that a US$1 (RM3.75) increase in jet fuel price would erode MAS' annual earnings by 24 per cent or RM60 million while a similar price increase would impact about 5 per cent of the earnings of AirAsia, Singapore Airlines (SIA) and Cathay Pacific.
"MAS and AirAsia are operating on difference business models.AirAsia's lean cost structure is one reason why it is able to withstand the effect of high fuel prices," Lim told Business Times.
In comparison, he said, AirAsia has a more effective fuel price hedging strategy, while MAS fuel price hedging and fuel surcharge efforts were insufficient to offset the impact of the skyrocketing oil prices.
To date, MAS has hedged around 61 per cent of its fuel requirements for the first quarter and 65 per cent of its full-year requirements at a relatively high rate of US$62 per barrel.
In addition, he said, the fuel surcharge imposed by MAS is the lowest among the world's major carriers.
Lim said MAS' overall earnings outlook for the current financial year ending December 31 2005 would remain vulnerable to the volatile fuel prices, continued increase in staff cost as well as sluggish growth in the global cargo sector.
He is revising down MAS' full-year profit forecast by 26 per cent to RM194 million from RM262 million previously, to capture the higher-than-expected jet fuel price.
Lim has also downgraded the target price for MAS shares to RM3.60 and maintains an "underperform" call on the stock.
On AirAsia's missing its profit forecast, an analyst said it is merely due to aircraft shortage to support its route expansion.
Other than that, he said, the airline's business outlook remains promising and expect things to significantly pick up from December, when it will start receiving new aircraft.