Penn State News -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 4/7/1999
Last Visited: 7/27/2001
While the primary determinants of a judge's sentencing decisions are seriousness of the crime and the defendant's prior record , the three factors of race , age and gender clearly play a significant role , adds Dr. John H. Kramer , professor of sociology and former director of the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing based at Penn State.
Steffensmeier and Kramer , along with Dr. Jeffrey Ulmer , assistant professor of sociology at Purdue University , are co-authors of the paper , The Interaction of Race , Gender , and Age in Criminal Sentencing : The Punishment Cost of Being Young , Black and Male , which appeared recently in the journal , Criminology.
...
Women and older offenders were seen as posing less danger to community safety than younger Black males , Kramer says.Also , the culpability of women and older offenders was more often mitigated by prospects of being victimized themselves -- by coercion at the hands of men ( in the case of for women ) , drug/alcohol problems or psychological disorders..
...
Young Black males were seen as lacking such social bonds that were thought to insulate individuals from future criminal involvement , Kramer says.Indicators of stability and conventionality such as employment or care of others were likely to favor female defendants and least likely to favor young Black male defenders..
With the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing's responsibility to monitor the impact of sentencing guidelines and to reduce or eliminate unwarranted disparity , these findings suggest that the commission explore why young Black males who have prior records similar to those of Whites and have committed similarly serious offenses are treated more severely at sentencing.
* * * pab * * *
...
EDITORS : Dr. Steffensmeier is at ( 814 ) 863-1690 and ( 814 ) 466-6476 or at d4s@psu.edu by email ; Dr. Kramer is at ( 814 ) 863-2797 or at jhk@psu.edu by email.