A Funny Kind of Integrity | Press For Change -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 3/12/2004
Last Visited: 1/4/2007
The FIRST example concerns the curiously contradictory way in which the book cites the opinions of Professor Louis Gooren when it suits the argument, and trashes his team's work when it doesn't.
The book cites Professor Gooren's publications no fewer than eight times, and I'm sure he'll be flatterred by all that well-deserved attention.The Professor holds the world's only chair in Transsexology at the Free University Hospital in Amsterdam, where he heads a multidisciplinary team of endocrinologists, psychologists and surgeons, performing the very sort of medical reassignment treatment which the EA so-strongly abhors.
...
Semantically these are all referred to as "Intersex" though, and on occasions, therefore, Louis has been known to observe that you could therefore go a step further and put "trans" into the same bag as well.
...
Nevertheless note that here, on page four of the book, Professor Gooren's standing as an authority is rock solid enough to quote favourably.
Further into the book, on page 16, Gooren's work is quoted again, this time as an alternative opinion on the epidemiology of the trans condition.Again, so far so good.
...
Why Professor Louis Gooren, of course, in his Closing Speech to the Council of Europe's 23rd Colloquy, "Transsexualism, Medicine and Law".
...
All of which goes to show that Louis Gooren is a good deal better at keeping an open mind and entertaining all possibilities than those quoting his work!