Managers View As Mixed Blessing Proposed New Natural... -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 3/1/2001
Last Visited: 3/2/2004
Betsy Gagné, executive secretary to the NARS Commission, says the system needs three or four times the financial resources it now has."Everybody is tired of running in place," she says.
...
To Gagné and others, the hunters' concerns about losing prime hunting grounds are bogus.Altogether, DOFAW has responsibility for 800,000 acres, with roughly one acre in eight falling within the Natural Area Reserve System, she notes.More than half a million acres of DOFAW lands are available for hunting, she adds.Even if the reserve system acreage doubled, it wouldn't come close to what hunters already have, she says.
"People are used to going where they want to go," she says."People don't see the big picture."Referring to the important function natural areas play in recharging aquifers, she adds, "People don't know where their water comes from."
In a NAR on the Big Island, she says, a large amount of fresh lava was included.
...
Upon hearing the hunters' arguments, Gagné clamps her hands to her face and shakes her head.She's heard every theory in the book offered by hunters on the virtues of ungulates.
One question they ask all the time, she says, is, "`If ungulates are so bad for endangered species, why do they seem to occupy the same area?' Endangered species may exist where there are many ungulates, but they are declining.
...
Drawing lines on maps where game management will and will not occur is the biggest obstacle to solving the management problem, Gagné says, adding that in the NARS, "we don't have the leadership or the spine" to do what needs to be done.
...
The only way it's going to fly is if [conservationists] give up areas where there are few endangered species to game management, so that the rest can be better protected," Gagné says.
This may prove difficult since she says the "plant people" are just as bad with disagreeing with each other as the conservationists are with the hunters."At least the hunters agree with each other," Gagné says.