Welcome to GoErie.com -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 1/17/2003
Last Visited: 1/17/2003
Erie County Medical Society President Thomas Falasca, D.O., questions the validity of a report that ranks Pennsylvania as having the nation's highest rate of doctors who repeatedly lose or settle medical malpractice lawsuits.
One out of every 10 doctors practicing in Pennsylvania has lost or settled at least two malpractice lawsuits, according to a report published by Public Citizen, a consumer watchdog group.Nearly 5 percent of the state's 39,000 doctors has lost or settled at least three cases, the study said.Pennsylvania is rated first in both categories.
"I found the report to be incredibly one-sided," Falasca said."They used different criteria for (malpractice) payments: money received by the patient, money awarded by the jury, and money paid out by insurers.They continually shifted back and forth among those standards."
West Virginia ranked second in the nation in doctors who lost or settled at least two malpractice claims, at 9.3 percent, or 401 of 4,296 total physicians, according to Public Citizen.And 253 doctors of the 6,847 in Kansas accounted for ranking that state second in terms of three or more malpractice payouts.
...
But Falasca said that if the study's information is accurate, several explanations other than physician incompetence are possible.
"It could mean that Pennsylvania has a higher percentage of specialists, such as obstetricians, neurosurgeons and orthopedic surgeons, who are more likely to be sued than general practitioners," Falasca said."It could also mean that since Pennsylvania has a high number of medical schools and tertiary hospitals, we see more difficult cases that are more likely to attract lawsuits."
Insurance costs for Pennsylvania doctors more than doubled in 2002 for thousands of physicians.
...
"A federal bill would likely stem the flow of physicians out of state," Falasca said."It's what most physicians prefer."
...
"That statement doesn't even make sense," Falasca responded.