www.homegrownprosperity.org/media/worc_news_articles/pr -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 2/27/2003
Last Visited: 7/15/2008
"Consumers have a right to know where their food comes from, and farmers and ranchers want to meet U.S. consumers' preference for food raised in the U.S.," said Mabel Dobbs, a rancher from Weiser, Idaho, who chairs WORC's Livestock Committee."The United States Department of Agriculture is playing into the hands of opponents of the new country of origin labeling program who want to scare producers and consumers with inflated cost estimates," Dobbs said.
Congress adopted a new law earlier this year requiring that fresh meat, fish and produce be labeled by country of origin in grocery stores beginning in September 2004.The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) is writing regulations to implement the program.Last November, USDA estimated the cost of record-keeping by farmers, ranchers, food processors and retailers needed for the program at $2 billion.Dobbs submitted comments for WORC on USDA's estimate of the cost.
"Instead of looking to the known costs of labeling in other countries, under existing programs, and in states like Florida that already require labeling, USDA seems to have pulled these numbers out of thin air," Dobbs said."USDA estimated I'd have to pay someone $25 an hour for hours and hours of work to comply with this law.I don't pay myself that much, and I can tell you it isn't going to take me a minute to comply with this law.We already keep all the records we need to tell anyone who wants to know where our cows were born and raised."
"USDA added up a bunch of unsupported assumptions about costs.They double-counted, including costs that the government's own guidelines say should not be counted," Dobbs said.