Encounter with Emancipation: The German Jews in the... -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 4/19/2004
Last Visited: 11/1/2006
Author: Naomi W. Cohen
...
Naomi W. Cohen is a native of New York.She received her Ph.D. degree in history at Columbia University.At present she is Professor of History at Hunter College and the Graduate Center of the City University of New York.
...
In her comprehensive work Naomi W. Cohen offers impressive evidence to claim that "it was the German Jew--not the Sephardic pioneers nor the numerous Russian Jews--who laid the foundations of the modern American Jewish community."
...
With emancipation as the rubric for understanding German Jews in America, [the author] sees the American-Jewish experience as an extension of the western European Jewish encounter with modernity rather than as part of a distinctly American immigration ... Cohen makes an important contribution to the study of religion in nineteenth-century America through her thoughtful exploration of the relationship between religious liberty and religious equality ... Cohen draws largely on published sources, but she does far more than synthesize the fruits of past scholarship ... Future historians of American Jews--even social historians who look to different types of sources and ask other questions--will have to start their researches here.
...
In her introduction Professor Cohen warns that her book makes "no claim to all-inclusiveness."As a pioneering effort, it leaves much unsaid and many questions unanswered.It depends largely on English-language and secondary sources, and not always the most recent ones ...Still, this volume, which is the product of years of research and careful reflection, is a mature work.Professor Cohen builds her synthesis around the theme of Jewish emancipation, the political process that conferred citizenship and legal equality on Jews where they had formerly been second-class citizens ... Without being apologetic or anachronistic, [this book] offers something that American Jewish historical writing has rarely before provided, a past that speaks to contemporary concerns.
...
Cohen's detailed, fact-crammed work is an important addition to studies about Jews and Judaism ... {The author} deals particularly with the institutional responses worked out by the "reigning" German Jewish leadership who reacted to the "dilemmas inherent in emancipation," i.e., how to draw the boundary line between Jewish identities and cultural assimilation.Cohen (Hunter College and NYU Graduate Center) credits Jews from Germany and German-speaking regions of Poland and Austria with shaping the religious and secular philanthropic institutions and behavior patterns that prevail today ...A rich mixture, making no concessions to undergraduate, non-specialized readers, but a necessary book for all academic libraries, undergraduate level and above.
- Choice
Naomi W. Cohen has triumphally explored a neglected chapter not only of American Jewish history but of American history itself.The deftness with which she has handled an immense range of sources and turned them into a gripping, incisive narrative is a fresh tribute to her established skill as a researcher and writer.