www.thekansan.com/homepage/x124592289/Study-looks-at-re -
[Cached Version]
Published on: 5/22/2009
Last Visited: 5/22/2009
But Brian Bascue, superintendent of the Newton Recreation Commission, which oversees the Newton Activity Center, raised questions about the findings.
...
While Bascue is mentioned in the acknowledgements of the study, he said the NRC was not aware this type of analysis was being done.
A researcher from WSU contacted him via e-mail, he said, and he provided the operating budget and participation numbers for memberships and programming.
Bascue said he was never contacted by city officials in regard to the study, and he only found out a formal analysis was presented to the city commission after reading it in the Kansan the next day.
As for the findings, Bascue said with a proposed cost of $18 million for a new YMCA and $12.7 million for an expanded activity center, the economic impact would obviously be more.
But he raised some doubts about the numbers put forth in the study and pointed out three specific areas of concern for him.
The first had to do with the economic impact of jobs created by the facilities.
According to the study, an expanded activity center would result in a direct employment impact of 72 jobs in the first year, an indirect job employment of five jobs, and a one-job induced employment impact, resulting in a total employment impact of 78 jobs in the first year.
But Bascue said the NRC already employs about 125 people, and the number would be even higher in an expanded facility.
...
Bascue said current costs for the NRC run about $10 a square foot.
Another number Bascue noted was an anticipated first-year membership fee revenue of $3.5 million for a Newton YMCA.
That number doesn't line up with the just-less-than $1.1 million estimate from the FourSquare Market Study done in 2008, Bascue said. (That study was paid for by the city, USD 373, the Newton Area Chamber of Commerce and private sector, and results were released in May 2008.)
With a projected revenue that large, Bascue questioned why YMCA proponents don't simply ignore the NRC and its funding and continue with the plans.
"If they can generate $3.5 million a year, they should go ahead and build a facility," he said.