It was still dark when we awoke Thursday to catch an early morning seminar titled, A Brave New World - Responding to Shifts in the Selling/Buying Model. With yet another Nor’easter about to bear down on Manhattan, it would have been easy to flip on “Boomer and Carlton in the Morning” on WFAN and drift back to sleep. But we’re glad we made the effort.
The event, which was held at New York’s Waldorf-Astoria, was sponsored by Eloqua, Oracle and The Pedowitz Group. It featured a panel discussion that addressed the ongoing and dramatic changes in sales and marketing wrought by the Web.
There was little consensus, for example, on the wisdom of using social media as a sales and marketing vehicle. ”I can’t get behind anything until it works and what I see in social media doesn’t even come close to the hype its received,” said Greg Alexander, cofounder and CEO of Sales Benchmark Index and coauthor of “Making the Number: How to use Sales Benchmarking to Drive Performance.”
He added that social media can get in the way of the fundamentals. “A sales person has about 2000 hours of selling capacity annually,” Alexander said. “If time is chewed up building social activities that don’t result in business, you’re destroying that value and changing up that [sales] capability for something frivolous…I hope I’m wrong. [Social media] is neat and exciting, but right now there’s no proof that it’s an effective sales tool.”
Steve Woods, CTO of Eloqua and author of “Digital Body Language,” had a different take, saying that social media can fuel awareness about a brand, product or service. “Social media, looked at by niche, is about getting discovered,” he said. “Are b-to-b buyers on Twitter and Facebook or blogging themselves? No. But they go to Google and Bing.
“If you look at the data on search and what are people searching for in most businesses it’s three or four keywords in a search. In the deep key words most of the results are blogs,” Woods added. “There’s a depth of content to address a specific issue.”
In light of search results for a particular niche, b-to-b buyers are often engaging with social media without knowing it. “They’re a lot of social factors that go into Google rankings,” Woods added. “So executives don’t think they’re engaging with social media, but the [search] results are coming from social media. So if you’re not providing the content, your chances of getting high up in the search results are plummeting.”
The panel discussion also tackled the perennial question of how sales and marketing executives can work together more effectively. Alexander had a fairly jaundiced view. ”Sales and marketing shouldn’t work together,” he said. “It’s like asking Yankees and Red Sox fan to play nice. It’s not going to happen.” He added that companies are a “little too focused on closing the sales and marketing loop. But the dynamic says it can’t be closed. They are different jobs.”
Debbie Qaqish, chief revenue officer of The Pedowitz Group, which specializes in lead generation, said she “completely” disagreed with Alexander’s assessment. “You need to align sales and marketing to help close the gaps in the life of a lead,” she said. Woods added: “Sales and marketing executives are in the information industry. Companies get information from marketing and out of that information, sales can guide [buyer] behavior.”









Matthew,
well captured – I enjoyed the debates on the panel, and you did a great job of capturing the essence of them. Greg made some very compelling points that made me think carefully about my own views on social media. I look forward to hearing what the audience here has to say.
Steve
Interesting blog about the panel discussion. I got a similar reaction to a survey done with B2B Marketers in eastern MA. This in turn was supported by work done by Barbara Bix. See http://firealarmmarketing.com/2010/02/25/blogs-from-the-front-iii-social-media-networks/ for more details.
I side with Alexander on this. Chasing sales/marketing alignment is PC and generates a nice revenue stream for management consultants, but sales and marketing are symbiotic at best: mutually dependent in an organic sense. They work best together when they don’t mess with each other.
Steve, Robert and Shatterboxvox: thanks so much for your comments and links. The conversation on social media is just getting started while the sales-and-marketing equation, for better or worse, seems to be the status quo.
Hmmmmmmmm…let me think:
A usable web site, eNewsletters, SEO and therefore blogs and fresh cinent, still rate highly in my mind for B2B mktg & sales. Facebook, fanpages, twitter? Too soon to tell: I suspect more important for B2C. LinkedIn is great for connecting with professionals and possibly an aide in B2B.
For years we talked about CRM being the big profit maker. Now we’re not so sure based on the time commitment and the ROI.
C’Mon Man! Marketing and Sales have to learn to get along. Sales is part of the promotional construct of marketing. Marketing get’em to pucker, and a good sales person knows how to [close] collect the kisses.
Varitek gettin’ hands-on with A-Rod. Good stuff!
Hi John:
Thanks for your comment. Is it a fair image re the battles between sales and marketing execs? How do we break it up?
Cheers,
Matthew
Pingback: ‘Smarketing’ gets the pitch, but are b-to-b companies buying? « Follow The Lead